2023
6 Nominations
Outstanding Actress in a Musical, Melissa Felps, Urinetown
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical, Melissa Felps, Something Rotten!
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical, Clayton Humburg, Something Rotten!
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical, Jeffrey Izquierdo-Malon, Something Rotten! - WINNER
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical, Marshall Jennings, Something Rotten!
Outstanmding Director of a Musical, Scott Miller, Something Rotten!
2021/2022
8 Nominations
Outstanding Music Director, Nicolas Valdez, Head Over Heels
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical, Tiélere Cheatem, Head Over Heels
Outstanding Costume Design for a Musical, Courtney Gibson and Sarah Porter, Head Over Heels
Outstanding Actor in a Musical, Chris Kernan, The Story of My Life
Outstanding Actor in a Musical, Jeffrey M. Wright, The Story of My Life
Outstanding Ensemble in a Musical, Head Over Heels
Outstanmding Directors of a Musical, Scott Miller and Mike Dowdy-Windsor
Outstanding Production of a Musical, Head Over Heels
2020
6 Nominations
Outstnading Actor in a Musical, Zachary Allen Farmer, La Cage aux Folles
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical, Kevin Corpuz, Be More Chill
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical, Tiélere Cheatem, La Cage aux Folles - WINNER
Outstanmding Directors of a Musical, Mike Dowdy-Windsor and Scott Miller, Be More Chill
Outstanding Music Director, Nicolas Valdez, Be More Chill
Outstanding Costume Design for a Musical, Sarah Porter, La Cage aux Folles - WINNER
2019
9 Nominations
Outstanding Production of a Musical, Anything Goes
Outstanding New Play or Musical, The Zombies of Penzance
Outstanding Music Director, Nicolas Valdez, Anything Goes
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical, Zak Farmer, The Zombies of Penzance
Outstanding Costume Design for a Musical, Colene Fornachon, Anything Goes
Outstanding Actress in a Musical, Sarah Porter, Anything Goes
Outstanding Director of a Musical, Scott Miller & Mike Dowdy-Windsor, Anything Goes
Outstanding Ensemble in a Musical, Anything Goes - WINNER
Outstanding Ensemble in a Musical, The Zombies of Penzance
2018
11 nominations
Outstanding Production of a Musical, Lizzie
Outstanding Actress in a Musical, Anna Skidis Vargas, Lizzie - WINNER
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical, Marcy Wiegert, Lizzie
Outstanding Actor in a Musical, Matt Pentecost, Sweet Smell Of Success
Outstanding Ensemble in a Musical, Lizzie
Outstanding Director of a Musical, Mike Dowdy-Windsor, Lizzie
Outstanding Music Director, Sarah Nelson, Lizzie
Outstanding Music Director, Jeffrey Carter, Sweet Smell Of Success
Outstanding Choreography, Taylor Pietz, Sweet Smell Of Success
Outstanding Lighting Designer, Rob Lippert, Sweet Smell Of Success
Outstanding Costume Design, Sarah Porter, Lizzie
2017
4 Nominations
Outstanding Actress in a Musical, Sarah Porter, Tell Me on a Sunday
Outstanding Actor in a Musical, Zachary Allen Farmer, Atomic
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical, Zachary Allen Farmer, Celebration
Outstanding Music Director, Sue Goldford, American Idiot
2016
11 nominations
Outstanding Production of a Musical, Heathers
Outstanding Production of a Musical, Threepenny
Outstanding Ensemble in a Musical, Heathers
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical, Sarah Porter, Threepenny
Outstanding Actress in a Musical, Anna Skidis, Heathers
Outstanding Actor in a Musical, Evan Fornachon, Heathers
Outstanding Set Design in a Musical, Rob Lippert, Heathers
Outstanding Costume Design in a Musical, Sarah Porter, Threepenny
Outstanding Musical Director, Jeffrey Richard Carter, Threepenny
Outstanding Director of a Musical, Scott Miller, Threepenny
Outstanding Director of a Musical, Scott Miller, Mike Dowdy, Heathers
2015
15 nominations
Outstanding Production of a Musical, Bonnie & Clyde
Outstanding Production of a Musical, Hands on a Hardbody
Outstanding Set Design in a Musical, Rob Lippert, Bonnie & Clyde
Outstanding Costume Design in a Musical, Sarah Porter, Marcy Wiegert, Bonnie & Clyde
Outstanding Lightin Design in a Musical, Rob Lippert, Bonnie & Clyde
Outstanding Musical Director, Jeffrey Richard Carter, Bonnie & Clyde - WINNER
Outstanding Musical Director, Justin Smolik, Rent
Outstanding Ensemble in a Musical, Hands on a Hardbody
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical, Sarah Porter, Bonnie & Clyde
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical, Luke Steingruby, Rent
Outstanding Actress in a Musical, Larissa White, Bonnie & Clyde
Outstanding Actor in a Musical, Matt Pentecost, Bonnie & Clyde
Outstanding Director of a Musical, Scott Miller, Mike Dowdy, Bonnie & Clyde - WINNER
Outstanding Director of a Musical, Scott Miller, Mike Dowdy, Hands on a Hardbody
2014
7 nominations, 1 special award
Special Award for New Line Theatre's Body of Work
Outstanding Lighting Design in a Musical, Rob Lippert, Night of the Living Dead - WINNER
Outstanding Lighting Design in a Musical, Sean Savoie, Next to Normal
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical, Mary Beth Black, Next to Normal
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical, Ryan Foizey, Next to Normal
Outstanding Actress in a Musical, Kimi Short, Next to Normal
Outstanding Actor in a Musical, Zachary Allen Farmer, Bukowsical
Outstanding Director of a Musical, Scott Miller, Mike Dowdy, Next to Normal
2013
10 nominations
Outstanding Set Design in a Musical, Scott Schoonover, High Fidelity
Outstanding Musical Director, Justin Smolik, High Fidelity
Outstanding Choreography, Robin Michelle Berger, Cry-Baby
Outstanding Ensemble in a Musical, High Fidelity
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical, Terrie Carolan, Cry-Baby
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical, Mike Dowdy, Cry-Baby
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical, Zachart Allen Farmer, High Fidelity
Outstanding Actor in a Musical, Ryan Foizey, Cry-Baby
Outstanding Actor in a Musical, John Sparger, Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson
Outstanding Director of a Musical, Scott Miller, High Fidelity
For more info on the St. Louis Theater Circle Awards, click here.
To read New Line reviews and our honors from the press, click here.